The Republic of Moldova has been independent since 27 August 1991. Its western border with Romania runs along the river Prut; to the north, east and south, the country borders Ukraine. During World War II, the greatest part of its present-day territory was administered by Romania as ‘Bessarabia’ before June 1940 and between June 1941 and August 1944, and controlled by the Soviet Union the rest of the time. Between 1942 and 1944, Roma from Bessarabia were registered and deported to Transnistria, where many of them died.
Principality of Moldavia and Bessarabia (1812–1918)
The name Moldova can also refer to the Principality of Moldavia, also known as ‘historical Moldova’ in national narratives. In 1812, its eastern parts were annexed by the Russian Empire and renamed Bessarabia, a name that had previously referred only to its southern region, which is now known as Budjak. Its western part became a region of Romania called Moldavia in 1859. Budjak, along with Northern Bukovina and the Hertsa region, two other regions of the Principality of Moldavia, is now part of Ukraine.
In the Principality of Moldavia, the vast majority of Roma lived in a state of personal dependence, with the legal status of slaves and belonging to the prince, monasteries, or boyars. After the annexation of Bessarabia by the Russian Empire in 1812, this status of servitude was redefined: from that of a slave, it evolved into that of a serf, belonging either to the state or to a landowner. In the Principality of Moldavia, the enslaved Roma belonging to different legal categories were emancipated successively under a series of laws enacted between 1844 and 1856. In the Russian gubernia Bessarabia, Roma were the last serfs; their liberation took place after the reading of the Emancipation Manifesto of 19 February 1861 in the Cathedral of Chișinău.
Bessarabia (1918–1940)
The Roma of Bessarabia, which was a Romanian province from 27 March 1918 to 28 June 1940, numbered 13,518 people according to the general census of 29 December 1930. They were in the same situation as Roma in the rest of Romania during the interwar period. However, while there was a very active Romani intellectual movement in Bucharest and other major Romanian cities between the wars, no documentary evidence has been found that it had resonance among the Bessarabian Roma.
Moldavian Soviet Socialist Republic (1940–1941)
Following the secret protocols of the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact signed in August 1939 between Germany and the Soviet Union, Germany declared that it had no political interest in Bessarabia and implicitly accepted the territorial claims of the USSR. After less than a year and following a 24-hour ultimatum, Bessarabia and Northern Bukovina came under Soviet control on 28 June 1940. On 2 August 1940, Soviet Bessarabia, into which the Moldavian Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic (MASSR) created in 1924 was incorporated, was named the Moldavian Soviet Socialist Republic (MSSR). Six out of nine counties of Bessarabia and six out of thirteen districts of the former MASSR formed the MSSR, and the remaining counties and districts were attached to the Ukrainian SSR.1Casu, “Patterns of Succession,” 72.
According to some estimates, the withdrawal of the Romanian evacuation forces and the establishment of Soviet control claimed several hundred victims in Bessarabia. Even today, the question of the victims of this regime change remains unexplored outside the national narratives and fuels sensitive public and academic debates in the region. In the pursuit of traitors to Romania and formerly loyal officials of the Romanian administration in Bessarabia, as well as of those presumed to be unfaithful to the new Soviet regime, each side carried out reprisals against various population groups; in this context, the ethnicity of each person was scrutinised and could play a decisive role.
As for the Roma, there is little data on their presence among the victims during the regime change and the repression that characterised this first Soviet occupation. However, one hypothesis, based on the lists of deportees, suggests that there were Roma families among the individuals or families targeted during the first Stalinist mass deportation in the MSSR on the night of 12 to 13 June 1941. The number of victims under the Soviet regime in the MSSR between June 1940 and June 1941 amounted to more than 90,000 people of all ethnic origins.
Romanian Administration (1941–1944)
On 22 June 1941, the day when Germany invaded the Soviet Union, the situation changed again for the MSSR, which was renamed Bessarabia and placed under Romanian administration. Romania, under the regime of Marshal Ion Antonescu (1882–1946), joined the war against the Soviet Union alongside Germany.
According to the transcripts of the meetings of the Council of Ministers of the Antonescu government, a new administrative model was planned for Bessarabia and Northern Bukovina. By granting more freedom and autonomy, this new model was intended to be different from the one practised by the Romanian administration in Bessarabia between 1918 and 1940, and was to effectively erase all traces of the Soviet regime. General Constantin Voiculescu (1890–1955) served as the first military governor of Bessarabia and General Olimpiu Stavrat (1888–1968) became the second military governor in May 1943.
The new model was to be accompanied from the very beginning by ethnic cleansing, not only of Jews but also of all ‘foreign elements’. Mihai Antonescu (1904–1946), Minister of State and chairman of the meetings of the Council of Ministers in Ion Antonescu’s absence, declared on 17 June 1941 that a ‘policy of total and violent liquidation of foreign elements’ would be applied in Bessarabia and Northern Bukovina.2Ciucă, Stenogramele şedinţelor Consiliului de Miniştri, Vol. III, 570.
A census of the population by ethnicity was conducted in Romania on 6 April 1941. In Bessarabia and Northern Bukovina, the census took place in July 1941, just after the two provinces had been retaken. The population table, structured by ethnic origin, shows 8,204 Roma resident in Bessarabia. Among the eleven ethnic groups listed in this table, only Jews were not explicitly counted; a dash was entered instead. In Bessarabia (and Northern Bukovina), the Jewish population played an important economic role, and both provinces had large numbers of Jews.3Alʹtman, Holokost na territorii SSSR, 613; Solonari, Purifying the Nation, 222. According to the 1930 census and to the data of the Central Institute of Statistics from the same year, 204,858 Jews lived in Bessarabia.4Institutul Central de Statistică, Anuarul statistic al României, 1937 și 1938, 60 f. The policy of not including Jews in the census in Bessarabia and Bukovina was a decision of Marshal Ion Antonescu transmitted through Mihai Antonescu at the meeting of the Council of Ministers on 23 June 1941; he further explained that there would be a separate census of Jews.5Ciucă, Stenogramele şedinţelor Consiliului de Miniştri, Vol. III, 616 f.
According to certain estimates, several tens of thousands of Jews were murdered with the advance of the Romanian and German forces into Bessarabia between late June and early September 1941, while others, under varying conditions, were confined in ghettos in Bessarabia, and subsequently deported to Transnistria in the autumn of 1941. Only a small number of Jews escaped deportation and murder and remained in Bessarabia. These included individuals involved in ‘mixed marriages’ and their children, as well as a few dozen specialists whose skills were required by the administration.6Alʹtman, Holokost na territorii SSSR, 88.
In their oral history accounts of the Second World War, Roma frequently mention acts of violence against Jewish men and women in various rural and urban areas. One Roma man interviewed from the village of Parcani reported, amongst other things: ‘The gendarmes shot the Jews from Răciula […] that is, a Jew from Răciula, Haima, and even now the place where he was shot is a cursed place […]’.7Mihail (pseudonym), born in the 1930s. Interview by the author. Parcani, 18 July 2007. Another Roma man from the district of Drochia stated that ‘[…] the Jews were taken away by Hitler and Antonescu […] in Petreni hundreds of Jews were shot by the pond; the pond was groaning […]’.8Gheorghe (pseudonym), born in the 1920s. Interview by the author. Chetrosu, 30 July 2008.
Deportations
The criteria for determining ‘Romanian ethnic origin’ were not clarified for the administrative institutions in charge of the deportations. The Ministry of Justice of the Antonescu government, which was responsible for this question, worked on various laws in response to numerous requests from local administrations asking to which ‘category of Gypsies’ a certificate of Romanian ethnic origin could be issued. This certificate was an essential document for anyone wanting to practise a trade or profession under the Antonescu regime. The absence of a certificate could mean not only the loss of work but also the danger of being deported. Even though officials of the Ministry of Justice proposed the wording ‘Romanian-Gypsy’ for inclusion on certificates of ethnic origin, the situation of the Roma remained extremely precarious.
The Bessarabian Roma were subject to the policy of deportation to Transnistria from May 1942, when a Secret Census Order was issued throughout the territory of Romania, including Bessarabia. In stages, between July and November 1942, 2,237 Roma (135 categorised as ‘țiganii nomazi’ [‘nomadic Gypsies’] and 2,102 as ‘țiganii nenomazi’ [‘non-nomadic Gypsies’]) were deported to Transnistria from among the 8,204 Roma counted during the general census of Bessarabia in 1941.
The deportation of the presumed ‘nomadic’ Roma was carried out during the summer of 1942, on foot and in convoys, with a final checkpoint in the area called by the Romanian administration ‘Collection Zone for Crossing the Dniester’, which was located along the Dniester River [Romanian: Nistru, Ukrainian: Dnister] on the Bessarabian side. There were four crossing points in this zone: Tighina (the main one), Criuleni, Cosăuți, and Otaci.
An unknown number of these Roma died on Bessarabian territory on their way to Transnistria. Families tried to escape by various means. The case of the inhabitants of the village of Parcani (identified today by neighbours from surrounding villages as Roma but who describe themselves as non-Roma) indicates that they were under constant threat of deportation. To escape deportation, all the families of this village hid in the nearby forest for the entire summer.9Elena (pseudonym), born in the 1930s. Interview by the author. Parcani, July 2007.
The deported Roma were escorted day and night by gendarmes from one post to another, in convoys, with stops outside populated areas. The final post before transfer to Transnistria for many deported Roma was Tighina, the main checkpoint between Bessarabia and Transnistria. An interview with a descendant of a survivor includes accounts of an elderly Roma woman who was a partisan operating around this checkpoint and managed to evade deportation.10Nina (pseudonym), born in the 1940s. Interview by the author. Bălăbănești, 24 October 2014.
For the 2,102 Roma listed in the deportation records as ‘non-nomadic’, various means of transport were used in September 1942, often improvised. Only some of them were transported in one of the Special Trains, train number E11, on 16 September 1942.
It is difficult to know how many Bessarabian Roma lost their lives and how many were able to escape. But many Roma died in the camps and ghettos in Transnistria as a result of hunger, cold, and ill-treatment. The most recurrent theme in administrative reports about Roma deportees in Transnistria is the lack of clothing. This was the result of the ‘sanitary measures’ implemented by the administration for the ‘disinfestation’ of Roma, in view of the alleged high number of Roma infected with epidemic typhus.
Aglaia Arap (born 1935) from the Roma village of Ursari in Bessarabia recalls as her most vivid memory about the deportation the morning when an officer on a white horse came to collect them from the camp in Transnistria. Initially, she and her entire family believed that they were to be taken to a place of execution, and they were therefore surprised to discover that a public bath had been prepared. They left their clothes outside the entrance to the bath. However, upon finishing, they discovered that their clothes had disappeared from the doorway. On that day, the survivor recalls, many people died from the cold: it was winter.11Aglaia Arap, born in 1935. Interview by the author. Ursari, Spring–Summer 2007; Duminică, “Comunitatea romilor ursari din satul Ursari. Aspecte socio-etnologice,“ 263.
The question of returning home to Bessarabia was raised as soon as the first deportees arrived in Transnistria. Approximately 700 requests from Bessarabian Roma for repatriation were reported by the gendarmerie. Most received a negative response. Sometimes, the refusal was based on systems of categorisation and identification that dated back to the 19th century (for example, having had a grandfather who was a slave-cook in a boyar’s household), sometimes on political considerations absent from the initial reasons for deportation (for example, having been a trusted person of the Bolsheviks).
Moldavian SSR (1944–1991)
The Soviet resumption of control of Bessarabia in August 1944 and the restoration of the Moldavian Soviet Socialist Republic (MSSR) marked a political turning point lasting almost five decades, which ended with the dissolution of the USSR in 1991 and the proclamation of the independence of the Republic of Moldova.
From the very first days of the Soviet takeover, the Soviet authorities established control mechanisms for displaced or repatriated populations. Between 1944 and 1947, the People’s Commissariat for Internal Affairs of the USSR [Narodnyĭ komissariat vnutrennikh del SSSR, NKVD/MVD SSSR] operated a screening and verification point in Chișinău. Among those screened between January 1946 and February 1947, 36 Roma were included on a separate list, but their fate after passing through the centre remains unknown. Like the rest of the population of the MSSR, Roma suffered from the man-made famine of 1946–1947.
In the MSSR, the subject of the deportation of Roma and Jews from Bessarabia to Transnistria and their murder under Ion Antonescu’s regime was taboo throughout the Soviet period. While the ‘nationality’ (such as Moldavian, Bulgarian, Gagauz, ‘Tsygan’) of every Soviet citizen was recorded in their passport, all victims of World War II in the territories of the USSR were classified as ‘Soviet citizens’ without any distinction.
There is one exception to this, where Roma ethnicity features explicitly in an academic work published in Soviet Moldavia: the two volumes of a collection of documents about the MSSR during World War II, published between 1975 and 1976. Out of 1,102 documents in these two volumes, one five-line document, an excerpt from a report of the Civil-Military Administration Office of Bessarabia, Bukovina, and Transnistria, dating from 1943, is about Bessarabian Roma: ‘5. Governor Professor Alexianu (1897–1946) reports to the Marshal that the Roma evacuated to Transnistria present, from the standpoint of clothing provision, a pitiful picture: thousands of men, women, and children are completely without clothes…’.12Moldavskaia SSR v Velikoi Otechestvennoi voine Sovetskogo Soiuza, Vol. 2, 153. Apart from this mention, the deportation and murder of Roma remained invisible.
The only post-war legislative document concerning Roma in the USSR, including those in the MSSR, was a decree issued on 5 October 1956. The decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR ‘On the Integration into Work of Gypsies Leading a Vagrant Life’ [‘Ukaz Prezidiuma Verkhovnogo Soveta SSSR o priobshchenii k trudu tsygan, zanimayushchikhsya brodyazhnichestvom’] was very short and directive in tone. Those who did not follow the decree’s instructions risked exile for up to five years, accompanied by correctional labour. True to the carrot-and-stick policy, the Soviet authorities implemented the decree’s provisions throughout the 1960s and 1970s. One of the effects of this decree was the displacement of several hundred Roma (the exact number remains difficult to determine) from Soviet Ukraine and certain regions of Russia to the MSSR between 1966 and 1969.
Republic of Moldova (since 1991)
The first public discussions and publications concerning the deportation of Roma from Bessarabia to Transnistria under Ion Antonescu’s regime were initiated by a small number of Romani and non-Romani activists and researchers after the dissolution of the USSR and the proclamation of independence of the Republic of Moldova, especially in the 2000s.
On 22 July 2016, the Moldovan Parliament approved the Final Report of the International Commission on the Holocaust in Romania, chaired by Elie Wiesel (1928–2016). Since then, the victims of the Holocaust have been officially commemorated on 27 January, International Holocaust Remembrance Day. For a week, commemoration activities for Jews and Roma, both perceived as victims of the Holocaust, are organised in the capital city, Chișinău, and other towns and villages in the Republic of Moldova.




